Sony Dash vs. Chumby One: Battle of the "internet viewers"


Sony's Dash (left) and Chumby Industries' Chumby One (right)

Sony's Dash (left) and Chumby Industries' Chumby One (right)

Some of you might recall a few years ago, a little device made its way onto the gadget scene that let you wirelessly connect to the web so that you could see stuff. All kinds of stuff. It had a touch screen and even a “squeeze sensor.” It was called the Chumby. It was 2008, the iPad was still 2 years away and the Chumby was a bizarre but charming hybrid between an iPod Touch and a beanbag.

Based on open-source software with an embedded version of Adobe’s Flash, the Chumby runs apps that appear on its diminutive screen in a never-ending slideshow of information. If you’ve ever looked up at one of those elevator screens that show you headlines, weather etc., you’ll get the concept. I was immediately taken by the idea and hounded the folks at Chumby to send me one. Sadly, they wouldn’t do it since the Chumby wasn’t eligible for sale outside of the U.S. In the end, I gave up on ever getting my hands on a Chumby and moved on to other things.

It’s now 2010 and here’s what’s been going on with the Chumby in the intervening years…
It seems I wasn’t the only one who saw lots of potential in the cuddly little web-viewer. It ended up being named by Wired Magazine as a top gadget for 2008. In 2009 Chumby Industries created the Chumby One – a cheaper version of the original Chumby encased in hard white plastic instead of the Italian-leather exterior of its older brother. The Chumby One lacks the original’s squeezable form factor but introduces a large volume knob on the side and an FM radio. But perhaps more interestingly, Sony took notice of the Chumby platform and began development of their own internet appliance, the HID-C10, otherwise known as the Sony Dash, which they debuted at this year’s CES show in January. If the Chumby One is retro-looking clock-radio with a touch-screen, the Dash is a thoroughly modern wide-screen HDTV. Yet both devices run the Chumby widget platform, and now – for the first time – both devices are available to Canadians which means the time is ripe for a comparison.

Before we dive in though, here’s how the Chumby/Dash devices work, in case everything I’ve written to this point has left you wondering what I’m rambling on about. Feel free to skip to the specs if you’ve heard this before…

Sony's Dash has a modern, monolithic shape compared to the Chumby One's toy-like appearance

Sony's Dash has a modern, monolithic shape compared to the Chumby One's toy-like appearance

Chumbys and Dashs use your Wi-Fi network to connect to the web. After some minor configurations steps on the devices themselves, you use your PC or Mac to customize the content that the gadgets display through a dedicated website. The site lets you choose from amongst the 1000+ Chumby apps that are freely available, which you can then organize into “channels”. Think of Chumby/Dash channels as TV channels – you choose the kind of programming you want on each channel. Once set, you can “change channel” anytime from the device itself. Most folks will likely stick to a single channel, but having the choice to view others is handy.

Each app comes with its own set of customizable features. The Picasa widget lets you choose a URL with your photos, while the Weather Channel lets you choose your city and preferred temperature display (Celsius or Fahrenheit), and the Facebook Newsfeed app lets you “like” or comment on your friends’ updates – the latter via an on-screen keyboard. Others only let you choose how long they will remain on the screen.

App content runs the gamut from News to Travel and everything in between, but some categories are more populated than others. “Clocks” for instance has over 200 apps, which I suppose isn’t surprising given that these devices are primarily intended as desktop or bedside table companions. There are even some games you can play using the touch-screen such as “Reversi” or “Pinball” but frankly neither the Dash nor the Chumby One are especially good gaming gadgets.

Personally, I’ve gotten the most out of a combination of news, Facebook updates & photos, and humour. That’s the channel I keep running during the day. But I’ve also got a channel that runs a single app: Flickr. It runs continuously and turns the Chumby into an ever-changing digital photo frame. It’s also a great way to discover new photos as the app lets you see public photos by keyword – my suggestion: use seasonal terms like “autumn.”

Okay now that you know a bit more about how these Chumby-driven devices work, let’s get back to the comparison with a look at the specs…

  Sony Dash  Chumby One 
Price   $229 CDN  $119 USD
 Screen size  7″  3.5″
 Screen resolution  800×480  320×240
 Wi-Fi  b/g  b/g
 Video Playback  Windows® Media Video 9 (up to MP@HL 1080p)
Microsoft VC-1 (up to AP@L3 720p)
MPEG 4.10/H.264 (up to MP@L4.0 1080p)
 FLV
H.264
 Audio Playback  MP3, AAC, WMA  MP3, OGG, WAV, FLAC and M4A
 Audio-in  Microphone  Microphone
 Audio-out  Headphone jack  Headphone jack
 Speakers  Stereo, 1W+1W  Mono, 2W
 Power  A/C adapter  A/C Adapter with travel plugs or optional Li-ion rechargeable battery
 USB  1 USB 2.0 port  1 USB 2.0 port
 Accelerometer  Yes  Yes
 FM Tuner  No  Yes
 Ethernet over USB  No  Yes

A few things jump out at you when you look at this list.

First, the Dash is twice the price of the Chumby One. Actually it’s a little less than that since the Chumby One is priced in US$ and you’ll have to pay for shipping and possibly duties, whereas you can drop by your local Sony Store and buy the Dash – or via SonyStyle.ca. The Chumby One can only be bought online through their web store.

This price difference brings us to the other big difference: the screens. The Dash’s screen is likely the biggest reason for the extra bucks. It’s nearly twice the diagonal size and more than double the resolution. And though Sony doesn’t publish the details on its processor, I’m guessing it’s more powerful than the Chumby’s. That said, it is a very nice screen. Not razor-sharp like you’d find on an iPad or a laptop but still very good to look at.

Why the larger, wider screen on the Dash? In a word: video. Although Sony has chosen to “wrap” the Chumby experience in its own themed dashboards, the main reason the screen has 16×9 ratio is to facilitate video playback, something the Dash does much better than the Chumby. Most of the video-watching options are via a menu of streaming services such as YouTube and Netflix, but the unit can also play compatible video (and audio) files off of an attached USB key – at least that’s the plan. Currently the video portion of this feature is listed as “coming soon” when you try to use it. To be fair, Sony doesn’t promote this aspect of the Dash on their website but it’s tormenting to be offered the menu item and then not be able to take advantage The video quality is surprisingly good and while I didn’t try streaming full movies on the Dash (not quite sure why you’d want to) I did watch several of the movie trailers, some of which were in HD, from Flixster and the stream quality was rock-solid. Sound from the Dash’s internal stereo speakers is, as you’d expect from such a small device, on the tinny side but the volume is enough for the 2-3 feet experience.

The other video options on the Dash include: FIFA World Cup, blip.tv, Wired, Syle.com. FordModels, DailyMotion and many others. But the big omission from this list is Sony’s own Crackle.com free movie service, which launched in Canada earlier this year.

The Chumby One won't win any beauty contests but it sure is cute

The Chumby One won't win any beauty contests but it sure is cute

Video playback isn’t Chumby’s strong suit, but that’s not a deal-breaker and given the smaller size of the Chumby One’s screen, you probably won’t find yourself wishing it could handle more video.

Instead, the Chumby focuses on audio. The audio options include playback of several audio formats (see list above) from a connected USB storage device, various streaming services such as ShoutCast, podcasts from NYT, Mediafly and CBS, the ability to playback content from an attached iPod, or a collection of internet streams known as “Sleep Sounds” (rain falling, white noise, waves crashing etc.) – kind makes sense for a bedside gadget right? Makes you wonder why the Dash doesn’t have it. But the Dash does have native support for Slacker Radio, which for those who subscribe to the streaming service, will be a big plus.

While it’s true that the Chumby One only produces monophonic sound from its internal speaker, don’t let the cheap-looking plastic exterior fool you. Much like the Tivoli Model One – a mono desktop radio with a huge cult following – the Chumby One manages to pump out surprisingly rich sound. You can’t crank the volume very high, but it doesn’t matter; the sound that you do get is great.

The ironic thing here is that the Dash is arguably the natural heir to the Radio-Alarm-clock experience given Sony’s age-old domination of the category via their omnipresent Dream Machine product line. And yet the Dash lacks a built-in radio which has been a mainstay of the alarm clock for decades. The Chumby One on the other hand, has an FM tuner complete with an external wire antenna that tucks into the battery compartment when not in use. Speaking of batteries, shouldn’t all modern alarm clocks contain at least a back-up battery? The Dash has one that keeps the clock time from needing to be reset, but you’re still without functionality in the event of a power-outage. The Chumby One doesn’t have a backup battery but you can add one yourself and it not only helps in the event of a power failure, it lets the Chumby One operate completely cord-free for up to an hour.

Another great feature on the Chumby One is the ability to assign a timer to your audio playback. You can choose from 5 to 240 minutes in 5-minute increments before the timer shuts off the sound – great for people who like to fall asleep to music but who don’t want their dreams to have a soundtrack.

By now, some of you have noticed that the microphone – a feature of both devices – doesn’t appear to have a purpose. You’re right. So far, none of the Chumby apps or the Dash’s proprietary functions make use of the mic. I’m probably not alone in hoping that a Skype app will surface sooner rather than later… how cool would it be to chat via one of these gadgets from the comfort of your bed without needing a PC or smartphone?

Alright, it’s bottom-line time. Which of these devices should you buy?

My overall recommendation goes to the Chumby One. The cheaper price, great sound, uncluttered interface and retro-appeal make the Chumby One a very attractive choice. The more expensive Sony Dash doesn’t offer enough extra features in my opinion, to justify the extra dollars. That said, there are bound to be some who feel the premium is worth it in order to get the Sony brand name and reputation, the sophisticated dark-wedge design, the superior video playback and the larger, wider screen. If, for instance, you need a device like this for the kitchen, the Dash’s larger display would be a distinct benefit. Likewise, if you plan on using either of these gadgets as a serious digital photo frame replacement, the Dash wins again. However, after having used both devices – and given the plethora of options I have at the home and office for watching video and looking at photos, I feel the Dash’s extras are nice-to-haves but certainly not need-to-haves.

Advertisements

9 comments

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention Sony Dash vs. Chumby One: Which should you buy? | Sync Blog -- Topsy.com
  2. CJ

    Thanks for a solid review… hadn’t heard of the Chumby until now, and was considering a DASH. I’m now back in research mode :)

    Like

  3. Rajiv

    Great review. I just got the Dash for US$110 at Sam’s Club. Seems like a great deal at the price since most digital photo frames of that size cost at least 3/4 of the price.

    Any idea of what apps use the microphone on the Dash/Chumby? Is there Skype for Dash?

    Like

  4. Krusty

    My Chumby One just arrived here in Australia :) I googled “Chumby Discount” and found a coupon code that saved me $40, so very happy there! Loving the Chumby so far!!

    Like

  5. yerallnuts

    Well, I just (March 21 2011) bought a Dash (on spocial for $99 in Canada) and the hardware execution is gorgeous – Sony is the master of styling and paid close attention to the details – a built in sensor for the orientation of the device (standing up as a nightstand clock radio or laying on a desk) which even controls the illumination of the back-lit Sony logo.

    However the apps suck the big one – they stink – most are cheap looking, limited and buggy. Just how many variations of a clock does one need anyway?

    It would be nice (and appropriate) that the alarm clock be able to bring up the streaming audio player – but no. All it can do is annoy you with wakeup beeps. And if you want to play the radio you need to go into the menu mode – requiring a fairly large number of screen-touches to achieve.

    It would also be nice if it could connect with my local networked media resources and play my media, display my photos and so on. But no. It can only connect to a USB key (have not tried) Netflix (but not in Canada) or play Youtube videos and movie trailers from out on the Internet.

    It should pick up streaming radio stations that use flash (especially since there’s flash on board). But no; It can only connect to MP3 style streamers and those are dropping like flies.

    I’ve read that they believed that people would use this in their kitchens to help with recipes and such – without a browser that ain’t gonna happen.

    Great concept, but there’s little incentive for decent apps that are bug-free since no one gets paid for writing them (the eBay app is fairly nice, as far as it goes, but it would be better if it would hide until the last hour of an auction and/or bother you only when there are new bids or the status of the things you watch change). The Facebook apps are truly annoying and you can’t update your status or reply to a message from the Dash) – so it’s no wonder that the most obvious apps of all for this thing have yet to be written;

    – Skype client
    – VoIP client
    – Proper Facebook client
    – Proper Twitter client
    – Proper clock radio
    – Proper streaming radio with interface to the clock alarm.
    – Proper switch to sleep mode (the standby clock is just gorgeous – Sony is GREAT at styling).
    – Automatic time-of day display dimming (a photo-detector would have been a nice addition to the hardware)
    – Support for local media servers

    . . . . plus whatever other stuff this quick response has missed.

    Not sure if I’m going to return mine ($99 is below the threshold of pain), but it has little in it’s present functionality to deserve a place on my night table at this stage.

    As the device slowly sinks into the night and the executives at Sony wonder why this was yet another marketing failure, perhaps the answer is that it takes more than just a pretty face to get the public to buy in to the concept – there is no substance behind this potentially popular device – now, perhaps if they embedded Android into it . . . . . . . .

    Like

  6. Mark

    It’s all about value. I ended up buying both for $120 on Woot. No regrets,two really fun devices. I agree, a Skype app utilizing the mic would be great.

    Like