U.S. considering making camera phones "click"

Creepy-camera Ever wondered if that guy talking on his phone was actually doing more than just texting and chatting? One American Congressman thinks you shouldn’t be in any doubt.

Ars Technica, as usual, has unearthed a juicy piece of proposed legislation from south of the border. The Camera Phone Predator Alert Act as it is being called, wants all manufacturers of camera-equipped cellphones to make a shutter noise mandatory for the user.

In other words, it would be impossible to snap a pic with your phone without some kind of audible sound being played at a loudness level that has only been described as “audible within a reasonable radius of the phone”.

Clearly the proposal comes from the right place – the bill’s author, Representative Peter King of New York – wants to protect children and others from being exploited without their knowledge.

The question is whether the proposal makes sense in the real world. Would it stop cyber-creeps from taking questionable photos or merely force them to crack open their devices to disconnect the speaker?

Ars suggests that were such a bill to become law, it should include the option for the user to choose the sound effect associated with the image capture, much like a ring-tone. But surely that would defeat the purpose of the bill… if any sound can be the click of the camera, will we become desensitized to every sound?

This concept isn’t new. Korea has already enacted similar legislation, as has Japan (thanks Iria).

While the proposed Act would only make the shutter-sound a requirement in the U.S., it’s possible that manufacturers, in wanting to keep production runs simpler, could include this ‘feature’ on our devices too.

Do you think camera phones should be required by law to make an audible ‘click’ sound when photos are taken?
( polls)



  1. Iria

    Geez, this is already done in Japan, so the comment about "it's unlikely that manufacturers would want to sell a different version for Canada and could potentially include this 'feature' on our devices too" is totally wrong. In fact, in Japan, even the iPhone has the feature.


  2. TimR

    mmm yea but what if we ever came upon a crime in progress like photographing a murder if he heard the cell snappin away he would be chasin us down there goes the evidence for the cops to catch their guy and he gets away scott free


  3. doug

    These creeps want everyone to pay for a feature that prevents u from secretly photographing unlawful acts by politicians? And the excuse is to prevent pervs taking pictures of indecently dressed girls? Dress the girls,lock up this politician!


  4. Chris

    Yay.. another piece of control legislation, where the masses are punished for the stupidity of a few. Next thing you know, all cell phones will come with cords that we attach to our coats and thread through the sleeves so we don't lose them.


  5. jon

    This would be pointless. I have a program that many other people know about called bitpim. You can delete the shutter sounds in 3 seconds on virtually any cellular phone. Way to waste money idiots.


  6. mickj

    I see where this is coming from, and in theory, it's a good idea, but pretty much pointless when you think about where the preditors are gonna be- noisy playgrounds and the like…


  7. sarah01

    We have all brands of Mobile Phones,Ipods,Sidekicks,Nextels phone,Laptops for
    sell at cheap and affordable prices, they ranges from Nokia/Samsung/LG/Sony Ericsson/Motorola/Alcatel/panasonic With Bluetooth, all Brands and Models of
    Nextel Phones, we want you to get back to us with your quote so that we can
    begin a good business relationship. Note they are all Brand New T2 Euro specs,
    unlocked, no operator logo, come in their original sealed box, With 1 year
    international warranty from the manufacturer, English & Spanish manual,
    Finland made. We want to assure you that you will never regret buying from us
    because the delivery will be to your doorstep via UPS FedEx Courier service.And
    valid Tracking number shall be sent to you upon acknowledgement of
    Kindly acknowledge the reciept of our mail and get back to us at:


    Samsung P520 Armani====$330usd
    BlackBerry Storm 9500…..$350usd
    BlackBerry Curve 8900 …$300usd
    Nokia 8800 Carbon Arte..$600usd
    Nokia 8800 sapphire arte…$500usd
    HTC Touch HD ……….$500usd
    HTC Touch Pro ……….$400usd
    HTC Touch Diamond …$350usd
    Samsung omnia i900…..$400usd
    Apple iphone 3G 16gb……..$300usd
    Sony ericsson C905………$500usd
    Nokia n96 16gb…$400usd
    Apple iphone 16gb..$350usd
    Sony ericsson xperia x1..$400usd
    Apple iphone 8gb…..$300usd
    Nokia n95 8gb…….$300usd
    Ps3 60gb………….$300usd
    Samsung U800=====$380USD
    Samsung G900====$350usd
    Samsung U900=====$350usd
    Samsung i780===$340usd
    Samsung Serenata====$400usd

    Samsung Omnia (i900) Specifications:

    • HSDPA (up to 7.2Mbps) / 3G (2100MHz) / EDGE/ GPRS Class 12 / GSM

    • 5 Megapixel Camera with Auto-Focus & Power LED flash. Also comes with

    face and smile detection, Wide Dynamic Range optimisation and geo-tagging
    • 2nd VGA Camera for video telephony
    • 65K TFT WQVGA (240×400); 16:9 format
    • Multi-Format Music Support (MP3,AAC,AAC+,RM,WMA)
    • Background Music Play
    • FM Radio
    • Light Sensor / Motion Sensor with automatic screen rotation and

    etiquette pause
    • Digital Photo Frame
    • Video Recording (MPEG4, up to 640 x 480 / 3gp)
    • Video Playback (DivX, Xvid, MPEG4, H.263, H.264, WMV)
    • Video Editor / TV Out function
    • Bluetooth v2.0 EDR / USB 2.0 / WiFi 802.11 b/g
    • Windows Mobile 6.1 Professional
    • E-mail ( POP3, IMAP4, SMTP, MS PUSH Mail)
    • Windows Live with Windows Mobile Messenger
    • Offline Mode / Hands-free Speaker
    • Internet Explorer 5 (WEB) / Opera Browser (WAP)
    • Full Touch Screen
    • Optical Joystick
    • RSS Reader / Podcast Manager
    • Office Mobile / Internet Sharing
    • Java MIDP 2.0
    • Marvell PXA312, 624 MHz CPU
    • RAM 128MB, ROM 256MB
    • Support up to 1000 USIM contacts
    • Storage Memory 16GB or 8GB built-in Flash memory; MicroSD expansion slot

    tested up to 8GB
    • Size: 112 x 56.9 x 12.5mm / 122g
    • Phone battery capacity: 1440mAh
    • Talk Time: 5.8 hours (2G), 4 hours (3G)
    • Standby Time: 500 hours (2G), 400 hours (3G)